Cigale Grenache Shiraz Mourvedre 2004 ($19)
92 pts Wine Spectator Web Site (1/25/06)
Peter Schell and his wife Magali Gely came to the Barossa from New Zealand, but their hearts are in France, where Gely's family still owns vineyards near Montpellier. Their wine, a dead ringer for a Chateauneuf-du-Pape, is rich and spicy, with a gorgeous core of blackberry, blueberry and plum fruit, shaded with smoky white pepper notes that keep ringing through the long, beautifully balanced finish. Tannins are there but well-submerged. Best from 2007 through 2016.
After reading this review and before sampling the Cigale GSM, I had the following two questions:
1. Is this wine indeed a "dead ringer" for a Chateauneuf du Pape?
2. Is the finish long and "beautifully balanced" ?
The Skinny
Cigale Grenache Shiraz Mourvedre 2004 ($19)
- Imported by the Australian Wine Connection (no Website); 56% Grenache, 26% Shiraz, 18% Mourvedre; 14.9% alcohol; 800 cases made.
- Deep indigo in color with a wide, bright pink rim. The wine nearly defies gravity by clinging to the sides of the glass after swirling.
- The initial, overwhelming scent is of fresh concord grape juice. After 15-20 minutes of air time, the wine evolved scents of blackberry jam, dates, hints of Pernod (licorice/anise-flavored liqueur) and notes of black pepper.
- In the mouth, Cigale is very full-bodied and full of cooked berry flavors. It possesses soft, round tannins that stay in the background due the intense flavor and alcoholic heft. The finish is indeed long. However, I found the wine slightly hot (alcohol overpowers acidity) on the finish - not terribly balanced.
- I paired Cigale GSM to a roasted Portobello burger with mozzarella and artichoke aioli. The wine was a bit too hefty for food. If you enjoy extraordinarily big, intense Aussie reds, this might be a wine for you. As to my taste, I found it too overbearing - not recommended. However, I did notice that this wine was far less overbearing on day two. One suggestion for these types of wines is to decant them and let them breathe for several hours before serving.
To answer my questions:
1. I didn't find this wine to be a dead ringer for C. du Pape. It does have some similarity to 'modern', youthful C.d.P.s. However, I didn't detect any meatiness or herbs - which for me is always part of great du Pape.
2. The finish is quite long. However, I didn't find it to be well-balanced. It was definitely hot due to the high alcohol-to-acidity ratio.
Other reviews of this wine: Winorama
Technorati Tags: australia, austrian wine, wine, wine spectator, wine review
Recent Comments